Mifflin County's Kishacoquillas Valley — Big Valley — is one of PA's most distinctive farm regions.
General farmland in Mifflin County typically sells for $6,000–$12,000 per acre in 2026; premium tillable ground runs $12,000–$15,000, and wooded or recreational acreage runs $2,500–$4,500 (Central PA market).
The number that matters for your property depends on tillable percentage, soils, buildings, frontage, water, easements, and who is buying in your township — major market towns: Lewistown, Burnham, Yeagertown, Reedsville. Value swings widely with tillable percentage — the wooded ratio dominates pricing.
| Property type | 2026 indicative range (per acre) |
|---|---|
| General farmland | $6,000–$12,000 per acre |
| Premium tillable (best soils, frontage, buildings) | $12,000–$15,000 per acre |
| Wooded / recreational acreage | $2,500–$4,500 per acre |
Ranges are indicative 2026 market indicators compiled from the PA Farmland Values Per Acre report and regional sales patterns, updated November 18, 2026 by Aaron Glick. Every property prices differently — request a free valuation for a number tied to your specific farm.
The Kishacoquillas Valley is home to one of Pennsylvania's most established Plain communities. Generational farm operations dominate.
Big Valley limestone soils produce strong yields. Productive ground in this valley has been farmed for generations and shows it.
Land rarely changes hands in the Big Valley. When it does, the Plain community buyer pool is deep and acts quickly.
Mifflin County's farm market is centered on the Big Valley — the Kishacoquillas Valley between Stone and Jacks Mountains. This is generational farm country with a Plain community buyer pool that knows every farm and every family.
I market Big Valley farms with respect for how this market works. Local Plain operators often know about a property before the listing goes public. Reaching them right — on their terms, in their channels — is what gets the farm sold at the right price.
Whether your property is in Belleville, Reedsville, Allensville, or elsewhere in the county, the Big Valley network is real and matters.
Big Valley working tillable farmland in Mifflin County typically sells $7,500 to $12,000 per acre. Smaller Plain-community farms with buildings and good access often command higher per-acre prices due to the depth of local demand. Wooded mountain land runs $1,800 to $3,500.
The Big Valley Plain community is the dominant buyer pool, with expanding operations actively seeking ground. Add local working farmers, occasional ag investors, and hunters or recreational buyers for the mountain acreage surrounding the valley.
The Big Valley is smaller, tighter-knit, and almost entirely Plain-community-driven. Information moves through community networks rather than the MLS. Properties often sell before they're publicly listed. Marketing right means working with how the community actually finds farms, not against it.
I list and sell farms across all 67 PA counties — here are the nearest markets to Mifflin.
Free valuation. Local Mifflin County comparable sales. No obligation.
Talk to Aaron