Home/Blog/Farmland Investment

Buying Farmland as an Investment in Pennsylvania: What to Weigh Before You Buy

Farmland can be a steady, long-term addition to a portfolio — but it's not a get-in-get-out asset. Here's what I want you to weigh before you buy in Pennsylvania.

People ask me all the time whether farmland in Pennsylvania is a good investment. The honest answer is: it can be, for the right person, on the right parcel, with the right expectations. But it is not a fast or liquid asset, and it is not a guaranteed win. Let me walk you through what to actually weigh before you write an offer.

Farmland is an income asset and an appreciation asset

Most PA farmland returns come from two places: the income it throws off and the value it gains over time. The income usually comes from cash rent — a farmer pays you a set amount per acre per year — or a crop-share deal, where you split the proceeds with the person working the ground. If you want the full picture on leasing, this guide to passive income from your acres breaks down how those arrangements actually work.

The appreciation side is slower. Land values in PA have climbed steadily over the long term, but they don't move like a traded stock. You hold for years, usually decades. Patience is the whole game.

What actually drives the value

Not all PA land is equal, and price reflects that. The main drivers of value are soil quality, location, size, access, and water. Premium tillable ground with deep, well-drained soils commands top dollar. Smaller, awkward, or landlocked parcels trade for far less.

The numbers back that up. The average PA farmland runs around $9,560 per acre (USDA, 2025), but that average hides a massive spread. In Lancaster County, premium ground can go from $30,000 to $50,000 an acre. Up in the Northern Tier, the same acre might sell for $2,500 to $7,000. Before you fall in love with a price or a county, understand where the parcel sits in that range. Browse our county breakdowns to see how your target market compares.

Liquidity is your biggest hidden cost

Here's the tradeoff nobody puts on the brochure: farmland is not easy to sell quickly. If you need out for cash next year, a farm is the wrong place for it. It takes time to find the right buyer — often another farmer, an investor, or someone building a legacy purchase. And the sale can run months.

Real estate broadly is less liquid than listed securities, and farmland is on the slow end of real estate. Go in knowing this is a long-term hold. If your timeline runs under five, maybe ten years, seriously reconsider.

Farmland is a low-liquidity asset. Plan to hold it for decades, not quarters — and never put money in it that you might need soon.

Know yourself before you know the land

Because this is a slow asset, your own situation matters as much as the parcel. Ask yourself: Can I tie this money up for a long stretch? Am I comfortable with a tenant relationship — lease renewals, repairs, the odd dispute? Is this one piece of a broader plan?

Diversification matters here. Most advisors and farmers I talk to treat land as one slice of a portfolio, not the whole pie. If you already have a heavy concentration in one asset class, layering in illiquid farmland deserves extra thought. Everyone's situation is different, and this is not individual investment or financial advice — talk through your own numbers with a qualified professional before committing.

Financing looks different for investment buyers

Lenders treat an income-producing farm differently than they treat an owner-occupant buying a home and a few acres. Down payments run higher, terms differ, and underwriting leans on the ground's income potential, not just your paycheck.

Find a lender who genuinely knows farm ground. A banker who only does residential deals will mis-price your loan and slow you down. The right ag lender understands cash rent, yield potential, and how the parcel actually produces. Read more on PA farmland fundamentals while you shop rates.

Do the on-the-ground homework before you buy

Before you sign anything, look hard at the land itself. Get a soil test — it tells you what the ground will actually grow and whether you're inheriting fertility problems. Confirm water access and rights. Walk the boundaries. Check access and easements, so you're not buying a tract nobody can legally reach.

And verify the rent. If you're buying with income in mind, ask what the parcel currently rents for and whether that's realistic going forward. A good deal on price is only half the story; a parcel that doesn't produce is a poor investment at any price.

Focus on the right geography

Where you buy is as important as what you buy. Again, PA prices swing wildly — the rich cash-crop ground of Lancaster and other top tillable counties sits at one extreme, and more affordable recreation or pasture ground up north sits at the other. Neither is inherently better; it depends on your goals. Want steady rental income on proven ground? Pay for the premier counties. Want to build value in a more affordable region over time? The Northern Tier may fit. Get a free farm valuation to see where a specific parcel lands.

The bottom line

Farmland in Pennsylvania can earn steady income and appreciate over the long haul — but it's slow, low-liquidity, and loaded with specific quirks around soil, financing, and tenants. It rewards patient, hands-on owners who buy the right ground in the right place. If that fits your plan, it can be a genuinely strong move. If you need quick cash flow or short timelines, it's likely the wrong tool.

This article is for general information only and is not individual investment or financial advice. Every buyer's situation differs — consult a qualified advisor before making investment decisions.

Know what your land is worth

Before you buy or lease farmland, the numbers should be on your side. Get a clear, honest read on value first.

Ready to see what a specific PA parcel is really worth — no guesswork?

Free Farm Valuation

Common questions

Is farmland a good investment in Pennsylvania?

It can be — for patient buyers who treat it as a long-term, low-liquidity asset. Farmland in PA can generate steady rental income and appreciate over decades, but it sells slowly and rewards owners who buy good soil in the right location. It's not a fast or guaranteed return.

How does farmland generate income?

Mostly two ways: cash rent (a farmer pays you a set amount per acre per year) or a crop-share arrangement, where you split the proceeds with the operator. Income depends heavily on soil quality, location, and whether the ground is actually rentable at a realistic rate.

How hard is it to sell farmland later?

Harder than selling a house or a stock, and slower. Farmland is a low-liquidity asset — finding the right buyer (often another farmer, an investor, or a legacy buyer) can take months, and the sale takes time to close. Plan on holding for years or decades.

What drives which PA farmland appreciates most?

Soil quality, location, size, access, and water are the main drivers. Premium tillable ground in strong agricultural counties commands top dollar, while more affordable regions sell for far less. Understanding where a parcel sits in that range matters more than any single average.

Do I need a farm lender to buy as an investor?

It helps a lot. Investment and owner-occupied loans are underwritten differently — ag lenders understand cash rent, yield capacity, and how the parcel actually produces. A residential-only lender may mis-price your loan or slow things down.

Aaron Glick — Pennsylvania Farm and Land REALTOR®

Aaron Glick

Pennsylvania Farm & Land REALTOR® with Lime House Realty. Real Producers Top 500 Agent for South Central Pennsylvania in 2025. Serving all 67 PA counties from York, PA. About Aaron · Contact

Free Pennsylvania Farm Valuation

Find out what your farm is worth.

Free, confidential, no obligation. I cover all 67 PA counties.

Talk to Aaron